Countercurrent

Status Quo: European flashpoints

Weekly observation: where essential services are contested, who gains and who bears the costs

Week in review · Wk 46 · 9–15 Nov ·

Spain: on 12 November the Diputación Permanente confirmed RDL 29/2026 and repealed RDL 28/2026; the automatic extension of rental contracts therefore does not enter into force (BOE of 13 November). After Adamuz and Urda, the government, trade unions and the European Public Prosecutor's Office disagree about maintenance and EU funds; the causes are being investigated by the CIAF. Germany: the Federal Network Agency plans a surcharge on grid fees for households with solar installations at the end of the year.

boe.es 1boe.es 2

3 pain points this week: Spain · Germany

Spain Housing & Land

Spain/Cortes: Diputación Permanente votes on the rental decrees on 12 Nov, three days before the planned entry into force of the automatic contract extension

Royal Decree-Law (RDL) 29/2026 has been in force since 8 Oct: seasonal rentals require a verifiable reason, room rentals fall under the tenancy law LAU…

14 sources

Update 13 Nov: on 12 November the Diputación Permanente confirmed RDL 29/2026 and repealed RDL 28/2026 (BOE of 13 November). The mandatory extension by periods of five years (seven where the landlord is a legal entity) and the extraordinary extensions under RDL 28/2026 do not enter into force. What is in force →

boe.es 1boe.es 2

Positions according to the sources

  • Sánchez government, Sumar, EH Bildu, BNG; trade unions UGT, CCOO and tenants' unions (CSI)Housing is becoming an object of speculation; contract stability, rent caps and protection against eviction are needed.

    Housing is becoming an object of speculation; contract stability, rent caps and protection against eviction are needed. EH Bildu says the decree gives tenants and owners security and is aimed against speculation, not against small landlords. UGT and CCOO link the 24-hour general strike announced for 11 Nov with demands on housing and wages.

    Underlying values: Housing as a fundamental right, the common good, protection against displacementpressdigital.eselderecho.comelsaltodiario.com
  • Podemos (Ione Belarra)Podemos considers the decrees minimum measures and accuses the government of having split them ("Han hecho trampa", Ione Belarra).

    Podemos considers the decrees minimum measures and accuses the government of having split them ("Han hecho trampa", Ione Belarra). The central demand of the Sindicato de Inquilinas, open-ended leases, is said to be in the second decree, for which the government itself does not expect a majority. Before the vote on 2 Oct, Podemos left open how it would vote.

    Underlying values: Housing as a right, open-ended leases, limits on large landlordses.ara.cat
  • PP, Vox, UPN; Catalan employers' associations and representatives of small landlordsThe core problem is a housing shortage.

    The core problem is a housing shortage. PP deputy Sayas sees the decree as an attack on private property and legal certainty that makes access to renting harder. PP representative Bravo cites a shortfall of more than 700,000 homes; the employers' associations point to burdens on small landlords and the lack of any expansion of supply.

    Underlying values: Protection of property, legal certainty, expanding supply through constructiondiariodeavisos.elespanol.compressdigital.eseldiario.es
  • Junts, PNV, Coalición CanariaJunts calls for a voluntary rather than mandatory extension of up to two years, combined with tax benefits for landlords, and for a new round of negotiation.

    Junts calls for a voluntary rather than mandatory extension of up to two years, combined with tax benefits for landlords, and for a new round of negotiation. Coalición Canaria backs the first decree but rejects the second, because automatic extension and compensation could reduce the supply of rentals and hit small landlords. The PNV is reported to be set to back the first decree and reject the second.

    Underlying values: Freedom of contract with incentives, balance between tenants' and landlords' interestsque.espressdigital.eseldiariodemadrid.es
Who gains, who bears the costsIf the Diputación Permanente confirms both decrees on 12 Nov, so that RDL 28/2026 enters into force on 15 Nov

If the Diputación Permanente confirms both decrees on 12 Nov, so that RDL 28/2026 enters into force on 15 Nov

gains

  • Tenants of primary residences whose contracts are expiring: If the contract expires after 15 Nov, it is extended by five (seven) years without notice; if the landlord terminates, they must give six months' notice and, as a rule, pay compensation. Scale not documented
  • Tenants whose rent increases on the contract anniversary: The annual adjustment is 2% unless otherwise agreed; if the rent is above the state reference price index, the increase does not apply. The INE reference index IRAV stood at 2.54% annual change in September 2026; RDL 29/2026 sets a cap of 2% until 31 Dec 2027 absent an agreement. ine.es

bears the costs

  • Landlords (individuals and companies): Loss of the ability to end a lease or re-let on the previous timelines after the minimum term expires; obligation to pay compensation if they do not extend. Opponents expect a declining supply of rentals; the sources reviewed contain no evidence of this. Scale not documented

If the Diputación Permanente confirms only RDL 29/2026 and RDL 28/2026 lapses before it enters into force

gains

  • Landlords: The current rule remains: after five (seven) years the contract is extended annually by up to three further years, after which it ends without any obligation to pay compensation. Scale not documented

bears the costs

  • Tenants whose contracts expire after 15 Nov: No entitlement to automatic extension by five (seven) years; losing the home after the contract ends remains possible without compensation. Scale not documented
Countercurrent reading (our own position):For people whose housing depends on their income, the length of the contract determines whether they can stay…

For people whose housing depends on their income, the length of the contract determines whether they can stay; this very provision hangs on an open majority in a rump body. The supply question raised by the opposing side is not backed by official figures in the sources reviewed, and neither is the relief for tenants. The decision before the election is thus made by parliamentary-group arithmetic, not by evidence.

Background: starting point and why it is stuck

Starting point

Royal Decree-Law (RDL) 29/2026 has been in force since 8 Oct: seasonal rentals require a verifiable reason, room rentals fall under the tenancy law LAU, and rent increases are capped at 2% until 31 Dec 2027 unless otherwise agreed. RDL 28/2026 was repealed on 12 Nov; it would have automatically extended residential leases by five years each time after the minimum term expires (seven years for legal entities), with compensation for landlords who do not extend; in addition, there would have been an extraordinary extension of up to one year in cases of social vulnerability and annual extensions of up to three years in stressed housing markets. Both decrees replace predecessor decrees that the plenary of the Congreso had repealed on 2 Oct; both now require confirmation by the Diputación Permanente, because the Cortes have been dissolved and elections will be held on 29 Nov.

Why it is stuck

In the plenary, PP, Vox, Junts and UPN formed a majority against both decrees on 2 Oct; in the Diputación Permanente the majority for both decrees is open. Decree-laws must be confirmed within 30 days; if the second falls, it never takes effect, and the dissolution of the Cortes and the election on 29 Nov leave hardly any time for a legislative procedure.

Next checkpoint: 12 Nov 2026: Diputación Permanente vote on RDL 28/2026 and RDL 29/2026; 12 Nov 2026: RDL 29/2026 confirmed, RDL 28/2026 repealed; 29 Nov 2026: parliamentary election.

14 sources

14 sources · Compare countries → · What can be done →

Germany Decentralised Energy & Grids

Bundesnetzagentur: Dispute over the prosumer surcharge on grid charges for households with solar systems, determination planned for year-end

In Germany, grid charges have so far been paid solely by network customers who consume electricity.

10 sources

Positions according to the sources

  • Bundesnetzagentur (President Klaus Müller)The system of grid charges no longer does justice to today's energy supply; generators are in future to contribute to grid financing.

    The system of grid charges no longer does justice to today's energy supply; generators are in future to contribute to grid financing. Prosumers would keep their full grid connection but would pay a lower energy price through reduced withdrawal. According to the draft's justification, the surcharge would on average not lead to a higher burden compared with regular end consumers; the BNetzA cites additional costs of under 100 euros a year.

    Underlying values: Fairness of costs between grid users, grid financing, requirements under European lawbundesnetzagentur.de 2bundesnetzagentur.de 3prometheus-recht.decleanthinking.de
  • Eleven federal associations, including BSW-Solar, GdW and Haus & GrundGrid charges should be based on actual use of the grid, not on whether someone generates solar power on their own roof.

    Grid charges should be based on actual use of the grid, not on whether someone generates solar power on their own roof. A legal opinion commissioned by BSW-Solar questions the lawfulness of the additional burden; the associations call for the surcharge to be dropped and point to the cuts to solar support planned by the federal government.

    Underlying values: Planning and investment security, charges based on the polluter-pays principle, support for decentralised generationerneuerbareenergien.det-online.de
  • BDEW (energy industry)The BNetzA should give more weight to feasibility and reduce complexity, regulate legitimate expectation protection for existing systems concretely…

    The BNetzA should give more weight to feasibility and reduce complexity, regulate legitimate expectation protection for existing systems concretely, and reject or refrain from feed-in charges and dynamic grid charges.

    Underlying values: Feasibility, protection of legitimate expectations for investmentsbdew.de
Who gains, who bears the costsIf the BNetzA sets the prosumer surcharge at year-end as in the draft

If the BNetzA sets the prosumer surcharge at year-end as in the draft

gains

  • Grid operators and grid customers without self-generation: According to the draft's justification, higher base prices offset the lower grid revenues caused by self-generation; grid costs are spread across more payers. Scale not documented

bears the costs

  • Households and small businesses with PV systems (excluding plug-in solar): Surcharge of 70 to 90 percent on the grid base price from 1 Jan 2029; according to reports, the draft contains no transition period for existing systems. The BNetzA puts the additional costs at under 100 euros a year. Scale not documented
  • Operators of storage systems and feed-in generators: Generators and storage are for the first time required to contribute to grid financing; according to reports, collective building supply is also economically affected. Dynamic grid charges for storage at the earliest in 2030, for feed-in generators at the earliest in 2032. bundesnetzagentur.de 3

If the BNetzA scraps or softens the prosumer surcharge, as the associations demand

gains

  • Households with PV systems and operators of collective building supply: No additional base-price burden; the economic viability of existing and planned systems is preserved. Scale not documented

bears the costs

  • Grid customers without self-generation and grid operators: Prosumers pay less in grid charges, which are part of the energy price; grid costs are spread across fewer payers, or grid operators receive lower revenues. Scale not documented
Countercurrent reading (our own position):For low-income households, the distribution of grid costs helps determine the electricity bill…

For low-income households, the distribution of grid costs helps determine the electricity bill; whether the surcharge relieves grid customers without a system is not backed by any official figure from this research, only by the BNetzA's own statement. At the same time, according to reports, the draft also affects collective models through which tenants could use solar power, and should be judged by that.

Note: ISCEER works in renewable energy.

Background: starting point and why it is stuck

Starting point

On 6 Aug the Bundesnetzagentur (BNetzA) presented the draft determination on the general electricity grid charge system (AgNes), which is to replace the Stromnetzentgeltverordnung from 2029. The draft provides for a surcharge of 70 to 90 percent on the grid base price for households with their own generation on the low-voltage grid from 1 Jan 2029, with plug-in solar devices exempt; the consultation ended on 18 Sep.

Why it is stuck

The BNetzA decides as an independent regulatory authority by determination, not the Bundestag; those who oppose it must rely on legal remedies after it is issued, and a legal opinion already doubts its lawfulness. Concentrated association and grid operator interests face dispersed households.

Next checkpoint: By 31 Dec 2026: planned issuance of the AgNes determination by the Bundesnetzagentur; 2027: follow-up determinations; 1 Jan 2029: start of the new system.

10 sources

10 sources · Compare countries → · What can be done →

Spain Mobility & Spatial Planning

Spain/Madrid–Seville: After Adamuz and Urda, government, unions and the European Public Prosecutor's Office dispute maintenance, control-centre rules and EU funds

On the Madrid–Seville high-speed line, the accident near Adamuz occurred on 18 Jan (46 deaths) and the collision near Urda on 28 Oct…

21 sources

Positions according to the sources

  • Ministry of Transport (Óscar Puente until his resignation; since then Vice President Carlos Cuerpo) and AdifPuente stated that the Atocha control centre was working under normal circumstances on 28 Oct; staffing in the regulation and control centres had risen from 1…

    Puente stated that the Atocha control centre was working under normal circumstances on 28 Oct; staffing in the regulation and control centres had risen from 1,008 (2016) to 1,762. Adif states that maintenance spending grew from €720 million (2017) to €1,120 million (2025). Cuerpo is to implement the safety plan decided by Puente: double checking of control-centre instructions in the event of signal failure, better warning messages, more training and better working conditions for control staff.

    Underlying values: State responsibility, reference to past investments, orderly implementationinfobae.com 2infobae.com 3cronista.com
  • Train drivers' union SEMAFSEMAF points to a letter to AESF and Adif from August 2025 on the condition of lines and demands that safety take precedence over the commercial interests of…

    SEMAF points to a letter to AESF and Adif from August 2025 on the condition of lines and demands that safety take precedence over the commercial interests of the railway companies. On 16 Oct the union complained that the safety measures agreed after Adamuz were blocked. SEMAF has scheduled strike days on 10 Nov and 12 Nov and did not withdraw them after the meetings with Cuerpo; according to the source, a causal link between the outstanding measures and the accident has not been established.

    Underlying values: Employees' experience in safety matters, safety taking precedence over cost-effectivenessherqles.com 1elperiodicodeceuta.esnewtral.esdiaridetarragona.com
  • CSIF, Sindicato de Circulación Ferroviaria (SCF), Adif works councilIn September, CSIF warned of shifts of up to twelve hours and up to five consecutive night shifts in train operations and infrastructure…

    In September, CSIF warned of shifts of up to twelve hours and up to five consecutive night shifts in train operations and infrastructure (according to CSIF, around 9,000 of the 12,000 Adif employees). The SCF criticised staff shortages and the Adif rule on scheduling working and rest times in traffic control; the works council wrote to Adif's management on 23 Jan. According to the source, it has not been established whether the employees involved in Urda were affected by these shift schedules; the Adif works council has announced a strike day on 17 Nov.

    Underlying values: Occupational health and safety, rest periods, staffing levels as a safety factorherqles.com 2eleconomista.espublico.es
  • Court of Audit (Tribunal de Cuentas), fiscal authority AIReF and European CommissionThe Court of Audit puts the compensation paid to Renfe for the free season tickets at €801 million (September 2022 to 2023)…

    The Court of Audit puts the compensation paid to Renfe for the free season tickets at €801 million (September 2022 to 2023), against an estimated cost of €556.3 million, and finds overcompensation; around 8.9 million season tickets were issued. The European Commission finds for 2018–2022 that funds for high-speed lines went mainly into new construction and that renewal played a minor role. AIReF wrote in 2020 that gross investment in high-speed rail (over €55,888 million for 3,086 km, 2018 prices) has not covered the depreciation of the assets since 2012.

    Underlying values: Budget control, preserving assets, proof of how funds are usedboe.es 2transport.ec.europa.euairef.es
  • European Public Prosecutor's Office (EPPO), AdifThe EPPO is investigating possible fraud involving EU funds for the renewal, safety…

    The EPPO is investigating possible fraud involving EU funds for the renewal, safety, signalling and communication systems of the Madrid–Seville line and gives no further details; it is the second investigation after one opened in March 2026. Adif points out that it had already reviewed the files concerned in December 2022 and found no indications of breaches of regulations; according to reports, no connection between the two EPPO proceedings has been confirmed. The presumption of innocence applies.

    Underlying values: Protection of the EU budget, rule of law, presumption of innocenceeppo.europa.euinfobae.com 1diariojaen.es
Who gains, who bears the costsIf Giving maintenance, control-centre staffing and binding safety rules priority over network expansion and fare subsidies

If Giving maintenance, control-centre staffing and binding safety rules priority over network expansion and fare subsidies

gains

  • Passengers on high-speed and regional services, especially those without an alternative to rail: Lower operational risk through additional checks, staff and maintenance; implementation of the announced double control at control centres would be verifiable. Scale not documented
  • Employees in control centres, maintenance and train operations: Limited shift lengths, more rest periods and a say in safety decisions, as demanded by SEMAF, CSIF and SCF. Scale not documented
  • EU budget: cohesion funds for the renewal of the Madrid–Seville line: Clear evidence of how funds are used would make review by the EPPO and the Commission easier. In 2024, the European Commission approved over €110 million from the ERDF for 435.2 of the line's 471 km. spain.representation.ec.europa.eu

bears the costs

  • State budget and taxpayers: Higher ongoing spending on maintenance and staff for an infrastructure operator; the amount is not officially quantified in the sources. Scale not documented
  • Travellers during the transition period: Further line closures or speed restrictions are possible; after Urda, Renfe kept services between Madrid, Ciudad Real and Andalusia suspended. Scale not documented
  • Rail users with discounted fares, if funds are reallocated: With tight budgets, fare subsidies could come under pressure. For comparison: the Court of Audit put the compensation for the free season tickets alone in 2022–2023 at €801 million. €801 million (Sept 2022–2023) boe.es 2

If Continuing operations, fare subsidies and new construction in the existing proportions, with only individual safety measures added

gains

  • Commuters and frequent travellers with season tickets: Season-ticket discounts remain; since 2026, the monthly pass for Cercanías and Rodalies costs €20, and €10 for young people. Monthly pass for Cercanías and Rodalies: €20, €10 for young people (since 2026) boe.es 3
  • Railway companies and construction companies: Planning certainty for operations and new-build projects; the line could return to full service sooner. Scale not documented

bears the costs

  • Passengers and employees bearing the residual risk: Open allegations about shift lengths, staffing and maintenance intensity remain unresolved until the CIAF reports; the unions announce further industrial action. Scale not documented
  • EU budget and Spanish taxpayers: If the EPPO finds irregularities, the Commission could review payments or demand repayment. Scale not documented
Countercurrent reading (our own position):Affordable access and safe lines are both part of essential services.

Affordable access and safe lines are both part of essential services. Countercurrent considers the fare subsidy right, but it does not replace maintenance: the Court of Audit documents the cost of the subsidy, the European Commission the priority of new construction over renewal, and AIReF that investment has not covered wear and tear since 2012. An official series of maintenance spending per kilometre, control-centre staffing and shift schedules is missing; it is the precondition for a judgement. The causes remain open until the CIAF reports.

Background: starting point and why it is stuck

Starting point

On the Madrid–Seville high-speed line, the accident near Adamuz occurred on 18 Jan (46 deaths) and the collision near Urda on 28 Oct (official figure: 69 deaths). The causes remain open: for Urda, the investigation body CIAF generally has one year to deliver its final report; for Adamuz, according to the sources reviewed, only a preliminary report submitted to the judge exists. Maintenance and operation of the infrastructure rest with Adif, supervision with the State Railway Safety Agency AESF; on 6 Nov the European Public Prosecutor's Office (EPPO) opened a second investigation into EU funds on this line and carried out measures at Adif, AESF and the Court of Auditors.

Why it is stuck

Responsibility is spread across the ministry, Adif, AESF, rail operators and construction companies; the supervisory body and the investigation body are themselves part of the ministry's structure, and the EPPO has also investigated at AESF and Adif. The CIAF investigation, court proceedings and EPPO proceedings are running in parallel, and their results determine the timing of measures, while the resignations of the minister and the Adif president mean the leadership is being refilled. The costs of higher maintenance fall concentrated on the state, while the benefit is spread across many passengers and employees.

Next checkpoint: 10 Nov 2026: scheduled SEMAF strike day (further ones on 12 Nov and 17 Nov) and the outcome of negotiations with the Ministry of Transport on safety rules; CIAF final report on Urda generally due by 28 Oct 2027.

21 sources

21 sources · Compare countries → · What can be done →

Next: 🧭 Taking part locally