Countercurrent

Status Quo: European flashpoints

Weekly observation: where essential services are contested, who gains and who bears the costs

Week in review · Wk 45 · 2–8 Nov ·

Spain: the re-issued housing decrees head for the vote on 12 November, with a general strike the day before and elections on 29 November. France, first entry: after its rejection in the National Assembly, the Senate is debating the 2027 social security budget; part of the health savings comes by decree.

2 pain points this week: Spain · France

Spain Housing & Land

Madrid/Spain: Housing decrees ahead of the 12 Nov vote – general strike on 11 Nov, new elections on 29 Nov

On 2 Oct, the Congress rejected two housing decrees from the government; on 6 Oct, the Council of Ministers adopted them again in slightly amended form…

15 sources

Update 13 Nov: on 12 November the Diputación Permanente confirmed RDL 29/2026 and repealed RDL 28/2026 (BOE of 13 November). The mandatory extension by periods of five years (seven where the landlord is a legal entity) and the extraordinary extensions under RDL 28/2026 do not enter into force. What is in force →

boe.es 1boe.es 2

Positions according to the sources

  • Government (PSOE/Sumar), trade unions CCOO and UGT, tenants' union (Sindicato de Inquilinas)The decrees are meant to protect existing tenants from the end of their contract and from eviction: an extraordinary extension of up to one year in cases of…

    The decrees are meant to protect existing tenants from the end of their contract and from eviction: an extraordinary extension of up to one year in cases of social vulnerability and annual extensions of up to three years in stressed housing markets, automatic renewal by five years each time (seven for legal entities), with a landlord who refuses it owing compensation of the higher of twelve months' rent or one month's rent per year of tenancy, and rent adjustments of no more than 2 percent a year until the end of 2027 unless the parties agree otherwise; purchases of homes below 70% of market value by buyers of non-performing loans and by large landlords are prohibited until the end of 2030. CCOO and UGT have announced a 24-hour general strike for housing and wages on 11 Nov; a UGT representative stated that housing must not be left to the market and the funds.

    Underlying values: Housing as a fundamental right (Art. 47 of the Constitution), tenant protection, common good before profit interestsboe.es 1boe.es 2eldiario.es 1newtral.eses.euronews.comelcorreodeburgos.com
  • Junts, People's Party (PP), Vox, UPNJunts argues that the measures would reduce the supply of rental housing and drive up prices, which would hit low-income households.

    Junts argues that the measures would reduce the supply of rental housing and drive up prices, which would hit low-income households. PP housing spokesman Juan Bravo considers the interventions in the market severe, without the housing shortage being addressed through new construction. These parties voted against the decrees in the plenary on 2 Oct.

    Underlying values: Protection of property, market mechanisms, expanding supply through new constructiontime.comaljazeera.comidealista.com
  • Business associationsThe employer side sees a political and election-tactical background to the general strike.

    The employer side sees a political and election-tactical background to the general strike. The strike falls two days before the start of the election campaign; according to eldiario.es, the government side expects the strike and the vote to mobilise the progressive part of the electorate.

    Underlying values: Entrepreneurial freedom, separation of collective bargaining disputes and election campaigningdeia.euseldiario.es 2
Who gains, who bears the costsIf the decrees are confirmed by the Standing Committee on 12 Nov

If the decrees are confirmed by the Standing Committee on 12 Nov

gains

  • Tenant households with expiring contracts and households threatened with eviction: Extraordinary extension of up to one year in cases of social vulnerability and annual extensions of up to three years in stressed housing markets; eviction protection until 2030; rent adjustments limited to no more than 2 percent a year until the end of 2027 unless otherwise agreed. Scale not documented

bears the costs

  • Landlords, especially large landlords and funds: Restricted ability to terminate contracts and raise rents; purchases of homes below 70% of market value by buyers of non-performing loans and by large landlords are prohibited until the end of 2030. For small owners, the decrees provide tax incentives and compensation for suspended evictions. Scale not documented
  • Public budgets: Compensation and tax incentives for owners as well as a purchase programme announced by the government burden the state budget; the scale is not officially documented here. Scale not documented

If the decrees are not confirmed and lapse

gains

  • Landlords and investors in the housing market: The restrictions on contract renewal, rent adjustments and purchases below market value from the decrees lapse; the 2023 Housing Law applies again, with implementation varying by region. Scale not documented

bears the costs

  • Tenant households with expiring contracts and households threatened with eviction: The protection from contract termination and eviction under the decrees no longer applies. Scale not documented
Countercurrent reading (our own position):For households whose housing depends on their income, the dispute is a test of whether tenant protection or expanding supply comes first – what is documented…

For households whose housing depends on their income, the dispute is a test of whether tenant protection or expanding supply comes first – what is documented is that both have so far not been adopted together. The protection for existing tenants will be decided on 12 Nov in the middle of an election campaign, not in a legislative process that also regulates new construction.

Background: starting point and why it is stuck

Starting point

On 2 Oct, the Congress rejected two housing decrees from the government; on 6 Oct, the Council of Ministers adopted them again in slightly amended form, and on 7 Oct they were published in the Official Gazette (BOE); RDL 28/2026 was repealed on 12 Nov. Among other things, they contain an extraordinary extension of up to one year in cases of social vulnerability and annual extensions of up to three years in stressed housing markets, the automatic renewal of leases on primary residences by five years each time (seven for legal entities) and eviction protection until 2030; they must be confirmed by Parliament within 30 days. The Standing Committee (Diputación Permanente) is due to vote on 12 Nov, after Prime Minister Sánchez called new elections for 29 Nov following the rejection.

Why it is stuck

The government has no majority in the Congress. In the Standing Committee, the government has no majority of its own. Responsibility for housing also lies largely with the regions, many of which are governed by the PP and which must themselves designate the zones with rent caps. Landlords' interests are concentrated and organised, while those of tenants are dispersed.

Next checkpoint: 12 Nov 2026: Vote of the Diputación Permanente on the two housing decrees (day before: general strike on 11 Nov); 29 Nov 2026: parliamentary election

15 sources

15 sources · Compare countries → · What can be done →

France Health & Care

Paris/France: 2027 social security budget in the Senate after rejection in the National Assembly – health spending cuts partly by decree

The government introduced the draft 2027 social security budget (PLFSS) on 1 Oct; on 23 Oct…

10 sources

Positions according to the sources

  • Government (Labour Minister Farandou, Health Minister Rist, Budget Minister Amiel)The draft is meant to reduce the deficit of the basic social security schemes from 21.8 billion euros in 2026 to 12.7 billion euros in 2027 and to limit the…

    The draft is meant to reduce the deficit of the basic social security schemes from 21.8 billion euros in 2026 to 12.7 billion euros in 2027 and to limit the growth in health insurance spending (Ondam) to 2 percent. It also contains funds for the first "maisons d’accompagnement" for people at the end of life.

    Underlying values: Budget consolidation, sustainability of social securityvie-publique.fralliancevita.org
  • Left-wing groups in the National Assembly, Rassemblement National and parts of the Républicains (vote on 23 Oct)The left, the Rassemblement National and the majority of the Républicains voted against the revenue section; the government majority largely abstained.

    The left, the Rassemblement National and the majority of the Républicains voted against the revenue section; the government majority largely abstained. According to an analysis by clair.vote, groups on the right and in the centre supported savings such as higher co-payments and lower hospital spending, while left-wing groups rejected them across the board.

    Underlying values: Left: access to healthcare regardless of income; right/centre: spending disciplineassemblee-nationale.frclair.vote
  • Professional associations (e.g. the freelance nurses' association FNI), senators across party linesThe FNI criticises that outpatient care receives considerably less growth than hospitals.

    The FNI criticises that outpatient care receives considerably less growth than hospitals. More than 60 senators have campaigned across party lines for the reimbursement of spa treatments (cures thermales).

    Underlying values: Security of care in the outpatient sector, preservation of existing benefitsinfizen.frofficiel-thermalisme.com 1
Who gains, who bears the costsIf the Senate essentially adopts the government text with the savings measures

If the Senate essentially adopts the government text with the savings measures

gains

  • Social security and the state budget: The deficit of the basic schemes would fall according to the government's plan; the health insurance spending targets would be met. Scale not documented

bears the costs

  • Insured people with high care needs and low incomes: The caps on co-payments rise by decree; according to NosParlementaires, households bear these additional costs entirely themselves. In addition, there are lower reimbursements for dental treatment, medical aids and patient transport. Scale not documented
  • Supplementary insurers (Mutuelles): According to NosParlementaires, the government text extends the "extraordinary" levy on supplementary insurers for 2027. Scale not documented

If the Senate deletes or weakens savings measures

gains

  • Patients and hospitals: The cuts deleted by the Senate would not take effect; however, increases in co-payments already adopted by decree apply regardless of the legislative process. Scale not documented

bears the costs

  • Social security (contributors, future budgets): The deficit would be above the government's target; the offsetting financing is open. Scale not documented
Countercurrent reading (our own position):For people who have to pay for their healthcare out of their income, what matters is that co-payments are rising by decree, that is…

For people who have to pay for their healthcare out of their income, what matters is that co-payments are rising by decree, that is, independently of the outcome of the parliamentary debate. Whether the Senate changes anything about this is open; what is documented is that part of the savings is being set by decree rather than by law.

Background: starting point and why it is stuck

Starting point

The government introduced the draft 2027 social security budget (PLFSS) on 1 Oct; on 23 Oct, the National Assembly rejected the text (Assemblée nationale, T.A. n° 358). The Senate received the text on 2 Nov in the government's version and begins deliberations on 9 Nov. Part of the savings in the health system, including the co-payments (franchises médicales), is being set by decree rather than by law.

Why it is stuck

The National Assembly has no stable majority: the left, the Rassemblement National and the majority of the Républicains rejected the revenue section, and the government majority abstained. Part of the health savings bypasses Parliament by decree.

Next checkpoint: 9–18 Nov 2026: Senate sittings

10 sources

10 sources · Compare countries → · What can be done →

Next: 🧭 Taking part locally